Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Troy Cox's avatar

Thank you for writing such an intelligent and thought-provoking piece. I especially resonated with your concept of phantom vocation. Many of us carry a range of passions, often interconnected by deeper motivations and life experiences. But as you pointed out, society tends to demand a simplified, easily packaged version of who we are—something keyword-optimized, digestible, and market-ready.

In America especially, identity is treated as both a sacred value and a sales pitch. We’re encouraged to be “unique individuals,” yet only within narrowly defined, commodifiable boxes: a job title, a demographic, a style, a lifestyle brand. Those of us who are multifaceted—who think or look or act outside the expected lines—are often labeled as confused, indecisive, or just “too much.” But in truth, that complexity often reflects growth, post-conventional thinking, and a refusal to flatten oneself for easy consumption.

It takes real courage, energy, and often privilege to resist the pressure to narrow yourself to one path. Especially for people like me—neurodivergent, with very specific interests and limited resources—exploring multiple callings feels less like indulgence and more like survival. Just launching one career can be an enormous task in our current system. Between KPIs, resumes, and hustle culture, the process often feels more like performance than purpose.

That’s why I believe systems like universal basic income could radically change what’s possible for people. If more of us had the security to take risks, we’d see an explosion of creative, unconventional paths emerge. Until then, the roadmap for multidimensional lives remains murky. The options are there—but they usually come with high risk and low guidance.

For instance, I once had an idea to open a laundromat with a speakeasy in the back. Some people thought it didn’t make sense—“Why would anyone want to drink while doing laundry?”—and honestly, I get it. Most people just want to get their clothes clean and leave. But that’s kind of why the idea appealed to me. It’s about injecting novelty and joy into mundane moments. Maybe it’s not the most practical concept—but it’s a conversation starter. It makes people pause and imagine something unexpected.

Ideas like that—strange mashups, imaginative risks—shouldn’t be dismissed so quickly. They can open the door to new ways of living and connecting. I wish we had more spaces, more think tanks, more cultural permission to dream out loud like that.

So thank you for giving me that spark this morning. I’m really grateful to have started my day with your words.

Expand full comment
Cara B. Strom's avatar

This was fantastic - felt like you were speaking to me. Just discovered your work. Thank you, Joel.

Expand full comment
1 more comment...

No posts